UX: Simplify concept of assigning Show Hosts and Show Owners (user)
Parent: [EPIC] Extend Show Management Area and improve ... (#149 - closed)
On the show view, currently there are two different dialogs to
- Assign show hosts (
profile) - Assign show owners (
useraccounts)
This often causes confusion, as even the terms and its meaning are not clear.
Find a way to either clarify the different concepts or even combining both in one dialog. So far it's not yet clear, if that's even possible in a meaningful way. Let's investigate.
There will be also a relation between user and host possible, possibly supporting such improved UI. At least it should be made visible (icon or rendering style), when such relation is existing.
Proposal
- For now we don't change the internal or visual logic of those related concepts. This will be addressed in [EPIC] Host and User Profile Managment (aura#41 - closed)
- We only update the terms. This will be done as part of rename fields in the Show Area (#249 - closed)
Designs
- aura #2061.0-alpha5 — Capable Capybara 🐖
- steering #1661.0-alpha3 — Playful Platypus ▶️🦦
- #2491.0-alpha3 — Playful Platypus ▶️🦦
Activity
- changed milestone to %1.0-alpha3 — Playful Platypus
changed milestone to %1.0-alpha3 — Playful Platypus
added P2 Radio ORANGE 94.0 discuss requires-refinement labels
assigned to @kmohrf
In the ProKo/Tech Meeting on 2023-06-06 Pawel suggested to add some sort of tooltip providing additional help:
Unterschied SRmacherin und Moderatorin ist nicht ganz klar. Brauchts da ein InfoPopup? Soll das User Interface grundsätzlich verbessert werden, dass es auch in der Bedienung logischer ist?
David: I see such tooltip as a possible, temporary workaround, but not a wholesome UX solution.
Edited by David Trattnigmentioned in issue #149 (closed)
marked this issue as related to aura#206 (closed)
marked this issue as related to steering#166 (closed)
In German language, one meaningful distinction is "Redakteur:innen" or even "Chefredakteur:innen" (as Owners) versus "Moderator:innen" (equals hosts), because the first signals the responsible role in curating a show while the latter can also be a guest or several persons. Once we find a consensus, this is also to be added into the Thesaurus.
-
The concept of "Chefredakteur:innen" not the type of differentiation intended by "hosts" and "owners" in Dashboard. "Redakteur:innen" vs "Moderator:innen" gets closer to its actual meaning, but still missing the main technical and organisational differentiation in Dashboard (users with editing permissions vs. publicly displayed hosts, without any way of possible interaction with Dashboard).
I suggest to have a call, where we can discuss the underlying concepts in Dashboard. Please feel free to suggest a date/time, where we can talk about it @fm_margarethem.
added To Do label
mentioned in issue steering#166 (closed)
-
Added info on relation between user and host will be provided in steering#166 (closed):
There will be also a relation between user and host possible, possibly supporting such improved UI. At least it should be made visible (icon or rendering style), when such relation is existing.
-
in discussion with @kmohrf we came up with the following suggestions to clarify both concepts:
a) owners could be called "Sendungs-Admin" (show admin) since the owner also has a user account to edit and administer the show
b) hosts can be called "Mitwirkende" / "contributors" (and then possibly differentiated more according to their roles)
In both cases, a short explanatory text below the term should help to clarify the concepts to users. (E.g. "Sendungs-Admin" - Person, die diese Sendereihe verwaltet, kann aber muss nicht identisch mit den Sendungsmacher:innen und Mitwirkenden sein)
@kmohrf adds another ticket regarding how to better represent different roles that the hosts may have.
Edited by Margarethe Maierhofer-Lischka removed requires-refinement label